zinit cli #41

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-03-09 06:09:24 +00:00 by despiegk · 1 comment

despiegk commented 2026-03-09 06:09:24 +00:00

Owner

Copy link

make sure we have proper zinit cli
and it has all features from the zinit sdk

make it easy to use

document it well

then test the full zinit cli for all the ftures

make clear plan, go step by step, this is a big one

make sure we have proper zinit cli and it has all features from the zinit sdk make it easy to use document it well then test the full zinit cli for all the ftures make clear plan, go step by step, this is a big one

despiegk commented 2026-03-09 06:13:06 +00:00

Author

Owner

Copy link

Comprehensive Implementation Specification: Zinit CLI Enhancement

Objective

Create a comprehensive, user-friendly CLI that exposes all SDK capabilities and RPC features with excellent documentation, intuitive commands, and proper ergonomics. The goal is to enable users to manage services and jobs through the command line with the same power and flexibility as the Rust SDK, while maintaining a clear, self-documenting interface that follows Unix conventions.

---

Current State Analysis

What Exists

CLI Argument Structure (crates/zinit/src/cli/args.rs):

• Service control: list, status, start, stop, restart, kill, remove
• Dependency visualization: why, tree
• Log viewing: logs (with unimplemented --follow)
• Configuration: reload, add (service/job subcommands)
• System: ping, health, shutdown, poweroff, reboot
• Debugging: debug-state, debug-procs
• Demo/Reset: demo, reset
• Interactive: tui (feature-gated)

CLI Commands Implementation (crates/zinit/src/cli/commands.rs):

• All basic commands implemented and working
• add service and add job commands exist but are basic
• Demo creates only 4 simple TOML services
• No job management commands
• No secret/credentials management
• No log filtering/querying
• No bulk operations beyond service control
• Missing advanced features from SDK

SDK Capabilities (crates/zinit_sdk):

• Generated OpenRPC client with 50+ RPC methods
• Fluent builders: ServiceBuilder, ActionBuilder, RetryPolicyBuilder
• Preset functions: simple_service(), oneshot_service(), system_service(), sleep_service()
• Demo generator with realistic examples
• Full type system for service/action/job configuration

What's Missing

CLI Coverage Gaps:

• No job-specific commands (only service-level operations)
• No run/execution history commands
• No secret management commands
• No advanced log filtering
• No batch operations commands
• No stats/metrics commands
• No action-level management commands
• Limited output format options (no JSON, YAML, table)
• No shell completion generation
• No configuration validation command

Documentation Gaps:

• No comprehensive CLI user guide
• No command reference documentation
• No examples for complex scenarios

Testing Gaps:

• No CLI integration tests
• No end-to-end test scenarios

---

Implementation Plan: 10 Steps

Step 1: Expand CLI Arguments & Structure (2 hours)

Define all new CLI commands and options.

• crates/zinit/src/cli/args.rs — ADD new subcommands
• crates/zinit/src/cli/mod.rs — ADD submodules

Step 2: Implement Output Formatting System (1.5 hours)

Create flexible formatting infrastructure (JSON, YAML, table, CSV, text).

• crates/zinit/src/cli/formatting.rs (CREATE)

Step 3: Implement Input Validation & Helpers (1.5 hours)

Create validation and error handling utilities.

• crates/zinit/src/cli/validation.rs (CREATE)

Step 4: Implement Service & Job Management Commands (2.5 hours)

Implement job, run, and enhanced service commands.

• crates/zinit/src/cli/commands.rs (MAJOR UPDATE)

Step 5: Implement Log, Secret, Action, & Config Commands (2 hours)

Implement logs, secret, action, config commands.

• crates/zinit/src/cli/commands.rs (continued)

Step 6: Implement Builder & Utility Commands (1.5 hours)

Implement build, completion, lint, stats commands.

• crates/zinit/src/cli/commands.rs (continued)

Step 7: Update main.rs & Integration (1 hour)

Wire all commands into main.rs dispatcher.

• crates/zinit/src/main.rs (UPDATE)

Step 8: Write Comprehensive Documentation (2 hours)

Create user guides and reference docs.

• docs/CLI.md (CREATE)
• docs/CLI_REFERENCE.md (CREATE)

Step 9: Create CLI Integration Tests (2 hours)

Test all CLI commands end-to-end.

• tests/cli/ directory with modular test structure

Step 10: Create Example Configurations & Recipes (1 hour)

Provide practical examples for users.

• examples/cli/ directory with sample configs and recipes

---

Acceptance Criteria

Functional

• All 60+ RPC methods exposed through CLI
• Output formatting works for all command outputs
• Input validation prevents invalid operations
• Error messages are user-friendly and actionable

Code Quality

• Code passes cargo fmt --check
• Code passes cargo clippy -- -D warnings
• No compiler warnings

Documentation

• CLI.md covers quick start to advanced usage
• CLI_REFERENCE.md documents all commands
• All commands have examples in help text
• Examples directory has practical samples

Testing

• CLI integration tests cover all command categories
• Output format tests validate JSON, table, CSV, etc.
• All tests pass: cargo test
• Test coverage > 80% of command code

---

Total Effort Estimate: ~16 hours

This is a comprehensive refactoring that will make zinit's CLI production-ready and easy to use.

# Comprehensive Implementation Specification: Zinit CLI Enhancement ## Objective Create a **comprehensive, user-friendly CLI** that exposes all SDK capabilities and RPC features with excellent documentation, intuitive commands, and proper ergonomics. The goal is to enable users to manage services and jobs through the command line with the same power and flexibility as the Rust SDK, while maintaining a clear, self-documenting interface that follows Unix conventions. --- ## Current State Analysis ### What Exists **CLI Argument Structure** (`crates/zinit/src/cli/args.rs`): - Service control: `list`, `status`, `start`, `stop`, `restart`, `kill`, `remove` - Dependency visualization: `why`, `tree` - Log viewing: `logs` (with unimplemented `--follow`) - Configuration: `reload`, `add` (service/job subcommands) - System: `ping`, `health`, `shutdown`, `poweroff`, `reboot` - Debugging: `debug-state`, `debug-procs` - Demo/Reset: `demo`, `reset` - Interactive: `tui` (feature-gated) **CLI Commands Implementation** (`crates/zinit/src/cli/commands.rs`): - All basic commands implemented and working - `add service` and `add job` commands exist but are basic - Demo creates only 4 simple TOML services - No job management commands - No secret/credentials management - No log filtering/querying - No bulk operations beyond service control - Missing advanced features from SDK **SDK Capabilities** (`crates/zinit_sdk`): - Generated OpenRPC client with 50+ RPC methods - Fluent builders: `ServiceBuilder`, `ActionBuilder`, `RetryPolicyBuilder` - Preset functions: `simple_service()`, `oneshot_service()`, `system_service()`, `sleep_service()` - Demo generator with realistic examples - Full type system for service/action/job configuration ### What's Missing **CLI Coverage Gaps**: - No job-specific commands (only service-level operations) - No run/execution history commands - No secret management commands - No advanced log filtering - No batch operations commands - No stats/metrics commands - No action-level management commands - Limited output format options (no JSON, YAML, table) - No shell completion generation - No configuration validation command **Documentation Gaps**: - No comprehensive CLI user guide - No command reference documentation - No examples for complex scenarios **Testing Gaps**: - No CLI integration tests - No end-to-end test scenarios --- ## Implementation Plan: 10 Steps ### Step 1: Expand CLI Arguments & Structure (2 hours) Define all new CLI commands and options. - `crates/zinit/src/cli/args.rs` — ADD new subcommands - `crates/zinit/src/cli/mod.rs` — ADD submodules ### Step 2: Implement Output Formatting System (1.5 hours) Create flexible formatting infrastructure (JSON, YAML, table, CSV, text). - `crates/zinit/src/cli/formatting.rs` (CREATE) ### Step 3: Implement Input Validation & Helpers (1.5 hours) Create validation and error handling utilities. - `crates/zinit/src/cli/validation.rs` (CREATE) ### Step 4: Implement Service & Job Management Commands (2.5 hours) Implement `job`, `run`, and enhanced service commands. - `crates/zinit/src/cli/commands.rs` (MAJOR UPDATE) ### Step 5: Implement Log, Secret, Action, & Config Commands (2 hours) Implement `logs`, `secret`, `action`, `config` commands. - `crates/zinit/src/cli/commands.rs` (continued) ### Step 6: Implement Builder & Utility Commands (1.5 hours) Implement `build`, `completion`, `lint`, `stats` commands. - `crates/zinit/src/cli/commands.rs` (continued) ### Step 7: Update main.rs & Integration (1 hour) Wire all commands into main.rs dispatcher. - `crates/zinit/src/main.rs` (UPDATE) ### Step 8: Write Comprehensive Documentation (2 hours) Create user guides and reference docs. - `docs/CLI.md` (CREATE) - `docs/CLI_REFERENCE.md` (CREATE) ### Step 9: Create CLI Integration Tests (2 hours) Test all CLI commands end-to-end. - `tests/cli/` directory with modular test structure ### Step 10: Create Example Configurations & Recipes (1 hour) Provide practical examples for users. - `examples/cli/` directory with sample configs and recipes --- ## Acceptance Criteria ### Functional - All 60+ RPC methods exposed through CLI - Output formatting works for all command outputs - Input validation prevents invalid operations - Error messages are user-friendly and actionable ### Code Quality - Code passes `cargo fmt --check` - Code passes `cargo clippy -- -D warnings` - No compiler warnings ### Documentation - CLI.md covers quick start to advanced usage - CLI_REFERENCE.md documents all commands - All commands have examples in help text - Examples directory has practical samples ### Testing - CLI integration tests cover all command categories - Output format tests validate JSON, table, CSV, etc. - All tests pass: `cargo test` - Test coverage > 80% of command code --- ## Total Effort Estimate: ~16 hours This is a comprehensive refactoring that will make zinit's CLI production-ready and easy to use.

despiegk closed this issue 2026-03-09 08:29:35 +00:00

Commenting is not possible because the repository is archived.

No Branch/Tag specified

Branches Tags

development

development_dioxus_bootstrap

fix/system-config-startup

development_mik_6_1

development_tty2

development_kristof

main

v0.4.0

archive/development_tty

v0.1.3

v0.1.2

v0.1.1

v0.1.0

v0.0.1-rc1

Labels

Clear labels

No items

No labels

Milestone

Clear milestone

No items

No milestone

Projects

Clear projects

No items

No project

Assignees

Clear assignees

No assignees

1 participant

Due date

The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference

geomind_code/zinit_archive2#41

No description provided.