broken merge — 46 unresolved conflict regions across 10 files on development #71

Closed
opened 2026-05-19 22:32:04 +00:00 by mik-tf · 3 comments
Owner

Symptom

development HEAD (ddff0eb) does not compile. CI's lab-publish.yaml (wired at s127) fails immediately on cargo build.

Root cause

Commit 6e39d677chore: auto-commit local changes before pull (despiegk, 2026-05-19 17:53 +0200) — is a merge of 93a3c99 (herolib_ai API migration) into 45efb36 (Casper's refactor(server): group flat src/ modules into rpc/ and jobs/ subfolders) that committed the unresolved markers instead of resolving them.

Scope

Files with marker counts:

file markers regions
crates/hero_slides/src/main.rs 42 14
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/generator.rs 30 10
crates/hero_slides_rhai/src/deck_module.rs 21 7
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/voice.rs 15 5
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/deck.rs 9 3
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/models.rs 6 2
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/prompts.rs 6 2
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/error.rs 3 1
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/lib.rs 3 1
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/discovery.rs 3 1
total 138 46

Why not unilaterally resolve

The two parents conflict on incompatible structural intents:

  • 45efb36 moved server modules into jobs/ and rpc/ subfolders (file renames + import path rewrites in main.rs).
  • 93a3c99 migrated herolib_ai API surface (ImageRef relocation from image_ref.rsdiscovery.rs, error variant renames, agent invocation rewrites in voice.rs/generator.rs/deck.rs).

Resolving consistently requires picking which side wins per concern. image_ref.rs still exists in tree (1727 bytes) and lib.rs line 51 still has pub mod image_ref;, so HEAD won partially — but the moved server modules (agent.rsjobs/agent.rs per merge stat) only exist at the new paths, so main.rs imports must take the incoming side. Mixing the two sides incorrectly will compile-break or — worse — silently drop one side's behaviour.

The original authors (despiegk + Casper) have the context to resolve this cleanly. Unilateral resolution by a third party risks corrupting either the refactor or the API migration.

Block radius

  • hero_slides CI permanently red on every push to development.
  • Blocks lab build --download of hero_slides assets for VM deploys — releases/tag/latest won't refresh.
  • Counts against the hero_skills#269 17/35 → 35/35 rollout.

Asks

@despiegk / @Casper — please reconcile 6e39d67 cleanly. Suggested approach:

  1. git reset --soft 45efb36 (or 93a3c99, whichever is the canonical base)
  2. Re-apply the other parent's commits with proper conflict resolution
  3. git push --force-with-lease origin development (or open a clean PR if force-push is unsafe)
  4. Verify cargo build --release --target x86_64-unknown-linux-musl --workspace passes locally before push

Once resolved, lab-publish.yaml will automatically refresh releases/tag/latest.

Surfaced by

s128 of the multi-session #269 rollout, which scoped hero_slides to ≤ 10 min based on raw marker count — actual scope is one-or-two-session co-author work.

## Symptom `development` HEAD (ddff0eb) does not compile. CI's [lab-publish.yaml](https://forge.ourworld.tf/lhumina_code/hero_slides/actions) (wired at s127) fails immediately on `cargo build`. ## Root cause Commit [6e39d677](https://forge.ourworld.tf/lhumina_code/hero_slides/commit/6e39d677) — `chore: auto-commit local changes before pull` (despiegk, 2026-05-19 17:53 +0200) — is a merge of [93a3c99](https://forge.ourworld.tf/lhumina_code/hero_slides/commit/93a3c99) (herolib_ai API migration) into [45efb36](https://forge.ourworld.tf/lhumina_code/hero_slides/commit/45efb36) (Casper's `refactor(server): group flat src/ modules into rpc/ and jobs/ subfolders`) that **committed the unresolved markers** instead of resolving them. ## Scope Files with marker counts: | file | markers | regions | |---|---|---| | `crates/hero_slides/src/main.rs` | 42 | 14 | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/generator.rs` | 30 | 10 | | `crates/hero_slides_rhai/src/deck_module.rs` | 21 | 7 | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/voice.rs` | 15 | 5 | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/deck.rs` | 9 | 3 | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/models.rs` | 6 | 2 | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/prompts.rs` | 6 | 2 | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/error.rs` | 3 | 1 | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/lib.rs` | 3 | 1 | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/discovery.rs` | 3 | 1 | | **total** | **138** | **46** | ## Why not unilaterally resolve The two parents conflict on **incompatible structural intents**: - [45efb36](https://forge.ourworld.tf/lhumina_code/hero_slides/commit/45efb36) moved server modules into `jobs/` and `rpc/` subfolders (file renames + import path rewrites in `main.rs`). - [93a3c99](https://forge.ourworld.tf/lhumina_code/hero_slides/commit/93a3c99) migrated `herolib_ai` API surface (ImageRef relocation from `image_ref.rs` → `discovery.rs`, error variant renames, agent invocation rewrites in `voice.rs`/`generator.rs`/`deck.rs`). Resolving consistently requires picking which side wins per concern. `image_ref.rs` still exists in tree (1727 bytes) and `lib.rs` line 51 still has `pub mod image_ref;`, so HEAD won partially — but the moved server modules (`agent.rs` → `jobs/agent.rs` per merge stat) only exist at the new paths, so `main.rs` imports must take the incoming side. Mixing the two sides incorrectly will compile-break or — worse — silently drop one side's behaviour. The original authors (despiegk + Casper) have the context to resolve this cleanly. Unilateral resolution by a third party risks corrupting either the refactor or the API migration. ## Block radius - hero_slides CI permanently red on every push to `development`. - Blocks `lab build --download` of hero_slides assets for VM deploys — `releases/tag/latest` won't refresh. - Counts against the [hero_skills#269](https://forge.ourworld.tf/lhumina_code/hero_skills/issues/269) 17/35 → 35/35 rollout. ## Asks @despiegk / @Casper — please reconcile `6e39d67` cleanly. Suggested approach: 1. `git reset --soft 45efb36` (or `93a3c99`, whichever is the canonical base) 2. Re-apply the other parent's commits with proper conflict resolution 3. `git push --force-with-lease origin development` (or open a clean PR if force-push is unsafe) 4. Verify `cargo build --release --target x86_64-unknown-linux-musl --workspace` passes locally before push Once resolved, `lab-publish.yaml` will automatically refresh `releases/tag/latest`. ## Surfaced by s128 of the multi-session [#269](https://forge.ourworld.tf/lhumina_code/hero_skills/issues/269) rollout, which scoped hero_slides to `≤ 10 min` based on raw marker count — actual scope is one-or-two-session co-author work.
Member

Implementation Spec: Resolve Merge Conflict Markers

Background

The bad merge commit 6e39d67 interleaved two independent changes:

  • HEAD (93a3c99) = despiegk's herolib_ai API migration: ImageRef moved into discovery.rs, error variant renames, new provider-based builder API throughout voice.rs/generator.rs/deck.rs/prompts.rs.
  • 45efb36 = Casper's refactor: moved server modules into jobs/ and rpc/ subdirs; had its own partial herolib_ai migration using the old AiClient wrapper.

The jobs//rpc/ subfolder structure is already on disk (committed in later commits on top of the merge). All remaining conflicts are about which API version to use. The correct resolution is always the new provider-based API from despiegk's side.

Resolution rule: for every conflict, take the side that uses the new provider-based API (no AiClient at call sites).


Files to Resolve

File Conflict regions Rule
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/error.rs 1 Take HEAD — "AI generation error: {0}" wording
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/discovery.rs 1 Take incoming — remove duplicate ImageRef import
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/lib.rs 1 Take incoming — pub use discovery::ImageRef
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/models.rs 2 Take incoming — &'static str returns
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/prompts.rs 2 Take incoming — new provider imports + builder API
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/voice.rs 5 Take incoming — remove AiClient, use direct providers
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/deck.rs 3 Take incoming — Arc import, remove stale, data_url PDF
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/generator.rs 10 Take incoming — new imports, builder API, &str param
crates/hero_slides_rhai/src/deck_module.rs 7 Take incoming — remove all let client = AiClient::get() lines
crates/hero_slides/src/main.rs 14 Take incoming — remove all let client + &client args

Implementation Plan

Step 1: Simple lib files (no interdependencies)

Files: error.rs, discovery.rs, lib.rs, models.rs

  • error.rs: Remove markers, keep "AI generation error: {0}" variant wording
  • discovery.rs: Remove conflict block (lines 10–14); the import is a duplicate since discovery.rs defines ImageRef inline
  • lib.rs: Replace conflict block with pub use discovery::ImageRef;
  • models.rs: Keep &'static str return types for basic_image_model / pro_image_model; keep resolve_image_model using .unwrap_or_else(|| basic_image_model().to_string())

Dependencies: none

Step 2: prompts.rs and voice.rs

Files: prompts.rs, voice.rs

  • prompts.rs: Take incoming imports (ContentPart, Message, ProviderCompletionsExt, openrouter_provider); remove stale use crate::ai_client line; take incoming ai_request body using builder pattern
  • voice.rs: Take incoming imports; remove all AiClient references; update run_cleanup signature (no client param) and body to use Arc::new(openrouter_provider()).completions()...

Dependencies: none

Step 3: deck.rs and generator.rs

Files: deck.rs, generator.rs

  • deck.rs: Take Arc import; remove stale ai_client + image_ref imports; take data_url PDF message construction
  • generator.rs: Take incoming imports (new herolib_ai types); remove stale ai_client/image_ref lines immediately after import block; apply new builder API throughout all 10 conflict regions; change image_model param to &str

Dependencies: Step 2 (voice.rs pattern establishes the data-URL PDF approach)

Step 4: deck_module.rs and main.rs

Files: crates/hero_slides_rhai/src/deck_module.rs, crates/hero_slides/src/main.rs

  • Both files: For every conflict, simply remove the let client = AiClient::get()... line (and any &client, arg it passed)
  • 7 conflicts in deck_module.rs, 14 conflicts in main.rs — all identical pattern

Dependencies: Step 3 (lib function signatures must be finalized first)

Step 5: Post-cleanup

After removing all markers, also delete:

  • generator.rs lines immediately after import block: use crate::ai_client::{AiClient, Provider}; and use crate::image_ref::ImageRef;
  • prompts.rs: any remaining use crate::ai_client line

Dependencies: Steps 1–4


Acceptance Criteria

  • grep -r "^<<<<<<\|^=======\|^>>>>>>" crates/ returns empty
  • cargo build --workspace compiles with no errors
  • No AiClient references remain in main.rs, deck_module.rs, voice.rs, generator.rs, prompts.rs, deck.rs
  • ImageRef is sourced from discovery.rs throughout
  • CI lab-publish.yaml passes on next push
## Implementation Spec: Resolve Merge Conflict Markers ### Background The bad merge commit `6e39d67` interleaved two independent changes: - **HEAD (93a3c99)** = despiegk's herolib_ai API migration: `ImageRef` moved into `discovery.rs`, error variant renames, new provider-based builder API throughout `voice.rs`/`generator.rs`/`deck.rs`/`prompts.rs`. - **45efb36** = Casper's refactor: moved server modules into `jobs/` and `rpc/` subdirs; had its own partial herolib_ai migration using the old `AiClient` wrapper. The `jobs/`/`rpc/` subfolder structure is already on disk (committed in later commits on top of the merge). All remaining conflicts are about which API version to use. The correct resolution is always the new provider-based API from despiegk's side. **Resolution rule: for every conflict, take the side that uses the new provider-based API (no `AiClient` at call sites).** --- ### Files to Resolve | File | Conflict regions | Rule | |------|-----------------|------| | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/error.rs` | 1 | Take HEAD — "AI generation error: {0}" wording | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/discovery.rs` | 1 | Take incoming — remove duplicate `ImageRef` import | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/lib.rs` | 1 | Take incoming — `pub use discovery::ImageRef` | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/models.rs` | 2 | Take incoming — `&'static str` returns | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/prompts.rs` | 2 | Take incoming — new provider imports + builder API | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/voice.rs` | 5 | Take incoming — remove `AiClient`, use direct providers | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/deck.rs` | 3 | Take incoming — `Arc` import, remove stale, `data_url` PDF | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/generator.rs` | 10 | Take incoming — new imports, builder API, `&str` param | | `crates/hero_slides_rhai/src/deck_module.rs` | 7 | Take incoming — remove all `let client = AiClient::get()` lines | | `crates/hero_slides/src/main.rs` | 14 | Take incoming — remove all `let client` + `&client` args | --- ### Implementation Plan #### Step 1: Simple lib files (no interdependencies) Files: `error.rs`, `discovery.rs`, `lib.rs`, `models.rs` - `error.rs`: Remove markers, keep `"AI generation error: {0}"` variant wording - `discovery.rs`: Remove conflict block (lines 10–14); the import is a duplicate since `discovery.rs` defines `ImageRef` inline - `lib.rs`: Replace conflict block with `pub use discovery::ImageRef;` - `models.rs`: Keep `&'static str` return types for `basic_image_model` / `pro_image_model`; keep `resolve_image_model` using `.unwrap_or_else(|| basic_image_model().to_string())` Dependencies: none #### Step 2: prompts.rs and voice.rs Files: `prompts.rs`, `voice.rs` - `prompts.rs`: Take incoming imports (`ContentPart`, `Message`, `ProviderCompletionsExt`, `openrouter_provider`); remove stale `use crate::ai_client` line; take incoming `ai_request` body using builder pattern - `voice.rs`: Take incoming imports; remove all `AiClient` references; update `run_cleanup` signature (no `client` param) and body to use `Arc::new(openrouter_provider()).completions()...` Dependencies: none #### Step 3: deck.rs and generator.rs Files: `deck.rs`, `generator.rs` - `deck.rs`: Take `Arc` import; remove stale `ai_client` + `image_ref` imports; take `data_url` PDF message construction - `generator.rs`: Take incoming imports (new herolib_ai types); remove stale `ai_client`/`image_ref` lines immediately after import block; apply new builder API throughout all 10 conflict regions; change `image_model` param to `&str` Dependencies: Step 2 (voice.rs pattern establishes the data-URL PDF approach) #### Step 4: deck_module.rs and main.rs Files: `crates/hero_slides_rhai/src/deck_module.rs`, `crates/hero_slides/src/main.rs` - Both files: For every conflict, simply remove the `let client = AiClient::get()...` line (and any `&client,` arg it passed) - 7 conflicts in `deck_module.rs`, 14 conflicts in `main.rs` — all identical pattern Dependencies: Step 3 (lib function signatures must be finalized first) #### Step 5: Post-cleanup After removing all markers, also delete: - `generator.rs` lines immediately after import block: `use crate::ai_client::{AiClient, Provider};` and `use crate::image_ref::ImageRef;` - `prompts.rs`: any remaining `use crate::ai_client` line Dependencies: Steps 1–4 --- ### Acceptance Criteria - [ ] `grep -r "^<<<<<<\|^=======\|^>>>>>>" crates/` returns empty - [ ] `cargo build --workspace` compiles with no errors - [ ] No `AiClient` references remain in `main.rs`, `deck_module.rs`, `voice.rs`, `generator.rs`, `prompts.rs`, `deck.rs` - [ ] `ImageRef` is sourced from `discovery.rs` throughout - [ ] CI `lab-publish.yaml` passes on next push
Member

Test Results

  • Build: success
  • Tests passed: 183
  • Tests failed: 0
  • Tests ignored: 2

All tests passed. The 2 ignored tests (test_generate_single_slide_ai) require a live AI service and are intentionally skipped in CI.

## Test Results - Build: success - Tests passed: 183 - Tests failed: 0 - Tests ignored: 2 All tests passed. The 2 ignored tests (`test_generate_single_slide_ai`) require a live AI service and are intentionally skipped in CI.
Member

Resolution Summary

All 46 conflict regions across 10 files have been resolved. The workspace compiles and all tests pass.

Changes made

The resolution consistently takes the herolib_ai API migration side (despiegk's changes), discarding the stale AiClient wrapper calls from the conflicting parent. The jobs//rpc/ subfolder structure was already on disk and required no changes.

Files resolved:

File Conflict regions Resolution
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/error.rs 1 Kept "AI generation error: {0}" wording
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/discovery.rs 1 Removed duplicate ImageRef import
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/lib.rs 1 Re-exports ImageRef from discovery
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/models.rs 2 &'static str returns for model ID fns
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/prompts.rs 2 New provider-based builder API imports + body
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/voice.rs 5 Removed AiClient, direct provider calls
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/deck.rs 3 Arc import; data-URL PDF message construction
crates/hero_slides_lib/src/generator.rs 10 New herolib_ai imports; builder API throughout
crates/hero_slides_rhai/src/deck_module.rs 7 Removed all let client = AiClient::get() lines
crates/hero_slides/src/main.rs 14 Removed all let client + &client args

Also removed stale use crate::ai_client and use crate::image_ref::ImageRef lines left after conflict removal.

Test results

  • Build: success
  • Tests passed: 183
  • Tests failed: 0
  • Tests ignored: 2 (live AI service required)

Next steps

Push development to trigger CI. The lab-publish.yaml workflow should now pass and refresh releases/tag/latest.

## Resolution Summary All 46 conflict regions across 10 files have been resolved. The workspace compiles and all tests pass. ### Changes made The resolution consistently takes the herolib_ai API migration side (despiegk's changes), discarding the stale `AiClient` wrapper calls from the conflicting parent. The `jobs/`/`rpc/` subfolder structure was already on disk and required no changes. **Files resolved:** | File | Conflict regions | Resolution | |------|-----------------|------------| | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/error.rs` | 1 | Kept "AI generation error: {0}" wording | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/discovery.rs` | 1 | Removed duplicate `ImageRef` import | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/lib.rs` | 1 | Re-exports `ImageRef` from `discovery` | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/models.rs` | 2 | `&'static str` returns for model ID fns | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/prompts.rs` | 2 | New provider-based builder API imports + body | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/voice.rs` | 5 | Removed `AiClient`, direct provider calls | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/deck.rs` | 3 | `Arc` import; data-URL PDF message construction | | `crates/hero_slides_lib/src/generator.rs` | 10 | New herolib_ai imports; builder API throughout | | `crates/hero_slides_rhai/src/deck_module.rs` | 7 | Removed all `let client = AiClient::get()` lines | | `crates/hero_slides/src/main.rs` | 14 | Removed all `let client` + `&client` args | Also removed stale `use crate::ai_client` and `use crate::image_ref::ImageRef` lines left after conflict removal. ### Test results - Build: success - Tests passed: 183 - Tests failed: 0 - Tests ignored: 2 (live AI service required) ### Next steps Push `development` to trigger CI. The `lab-publish.yaml` workflow should now pass and refresh `releases/tag/latest`.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No labels
No milestone
No project
No assignees
2 participants
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
lhumina_code/hero_slides#71
No description provided.